How Democrats Are Reclaiming the Politics of Populism

In the waning days of the midterm election, the Democratic Party of Bexar County, Texas, released an intriguing ad that interspersed contemporaneous news clips with archival footage of a 1990 speech given by Ann Richards, the last Democrat to serve as the governor of the Lone Star State, and its liberal grande dame. 1990 is long ago, but everything about Richards’s presence in the ad casts the mood even further back in time. She was already nearly sixty years old, with a white bouffant that must have required an E.P.A.-defying amount of hairspray to hold in place, and she spoke in populist terms that, two years before the triumph of Bill Clinton’s Third Way, might already have seemed dated. “I wanted to begin this program today with children,” Richards says, with a kind of revival-tent projection in her voice, “to say that that’s what the future of Texas is all about, and that we Democrats believe in the greatness of this country, and of this state, and we are not about to allow Texas to be sold to the highest-bidding Republican.” Her speech is interspersed with images of the current governor of Texas, Greg Abbott, who had declared that he wanted to make his state the “epicenter of A.I.,” and of Elon Musk, the world’s richest person, who has spent nearly two hundred million dollars bankrolling the allegedly corrupt Republican candidate for Senate, Ken Paxton. Back in 1990, Richards made the Democratic case in a tone that is both plaintive and thunderous: “There are things in our lives and in this state that are more important than money.”

Even in her own time, Richards was inimitable. But the Bexar County Democrats were onto something. In the present election, the Democrats are trying to do two things at once: introduce some fresh faces who might wash away the nursing-home veneer that has clung to the Party, especially in the wake of Joe Biden’s forced exit from the 2024 Presidential election, and change the terms on which American politics are argued. For more than a decade, the central subject of American politics has been the culture war, red states versus blue states, feminism versus the manosphere. But the underlying changes in the country have followed a different dimension—they have had to do with technology, money, and the escalating challenges of ultra-wealth and inequality. (The script for a closing ad for Amy Acton, the Democratic nominee for governor of Ohio, says, “Amy Acton is campaigning in this,” over a shot of the candidate next to a Jeep Wrangler. “Vivek Ramaswamy, in this”—news footage of the Republican next to a private jet. “That pretty much tells you what you need to know about these two.”) James Talarico, the Democratic U.S. Senate candidate in Texas, often says while campaigning, “The biggest divide in this country isn’t left versus right; it’s top versus bottom.” In many ways, the basic Democratic challenge this year is to try to make it so.

It is a propitious time for a little bit of populism. The intrusion of Musk into politics and of the A.I. hyperscalers, via data centers, into otherwise out-of-the-way American towns has made the issues of concentrated wealth and power especially poignant this year. Even more significantly, Donald Trump’s pursuit of policies that have exacerbated the central political problem of rising prices—the tariffs, the Iran war—combined with his financial entanglements and shadowy deals, has made him newly vulnerable to charges of using his public office for personal gain or, more simply, of being out of touch with Americans’ daily struggles. It’s been pretty easy, in other words, for the Georgia senator Jon Ossoff, who has called for a constitutional amendment to reverse the Supreme Court’s Citizens United decision, to forcefully denounce a “coin-operated” political system in a way that ostensibly blames both parties but really points the finger at Republicans.

The New Yorker Classics Newsletter

Bodyguard before this campaign. Now he has three. “When the President is constantly coming after you, there’s real consequences,” he told me. We were sitting in the back of his campaign bus, heading toward Caro, a rural town in the thumb of Michigan’s mitten. El-Sayed, slumped on a black leather bench, was keeping his gaze forward to avoid motion sickness. On his right wrist, El-Sayed wears a jumble of Taylor Swift-style beaded bracelets, and I asked him about one, which read, “FUCKING WOLVERINE.” He explained that, at a recent campaign stop in Michigan, Vice-President J. D. Vance had called him “a little weasel,” and added that he should “shut his mouth and show more gratitude to the country that gave him everything.”

El-Sayed had twisted the barb and hurled it back. “Nobody understands how deep and profound the gift of this country is like a kid who was born here but for the accident of history that allowed that to happen,” he’d said. “J. D. Vance called me a little weasel today. I’m, like, ‘No, no, no. What you’re talking about is a fucking wolverine.’ ” A supporter made him the bracelet, and handed it to him at a recent campaign stop.

Hate has played an arresting role in the late stages of Michigan’s Senate race, in which El-Sayed is facing the former U.S. congressman and Donald Trump ally Mike Rogers. At a rally in Port Huron early this week, Trump announced, “I’m here to keep a jihadist Muslim Brotherhood member from becoming a U.S. senator.” In August, Vance said, “There’s something about Abdul El-Sayed that is very, very evil and on the rise in the United States of America today”; he claimed that El-Sayed sees himself “as fighting for one group at the expense of others.” El-Sayed replied, in part, by calling Vance a “sock puppet.” On the campaign bus, he told me, “Donald Trump and J. D. Vance, because they’re fools, built me one of the biggest and best platforms of any incoming United States senator.”

Many recent polls show El-Sayed leading Rogers by only a few points, within their margins of error. “You need every vote here,” El-Sayed’s wife, Sarah Jukaku, told me. “It’s not like California, which is a huge state but you can take things for granted a bit.” A little-known part of his strategy is to run up a lead on the Upper Peninsula, which is home to only three hundred thousand people, or three per cent of Michigan’s population. El-Sayed performed particularly well there in the primary—in which he lost Detroit and Flint to the establishment candidate Haley Stevens—and the latest figures from the Detroit News show that he continues to be a favorite there, putting him nearly six points ahead of Rogers in the U.P. and northern Michigan.

Berikut beberapa detail laporan pendapatan toko kami dari beberapa tahun terakhir.

Sulit untuk melebih-lebihkan signifikansi dari apa yang terjadi di Texas malam ini. Sejak George W. Bush menggulingkan Ann Richards dari kursi gubernur pada tahun 1994, Partai Demokrat tidak pernah lagi berhasil memenangkan jabatan apa pun di tingkat negara bagian di sini. Prospeknya bahkan menjadi begitu suram hingga sebagian anggota Partai Demokrat rela mencoret wilayah-wilayah tertentu di negara bagian ini sebagai area yang mustahil untuk dimenangkan.

Dalam beberapa tahun terakhir, banyak anggota Partai Demokrat meyakini bahwa pemilih kulit hitam dan kelompok minoritas lainnya pada akhirnya akan menjadi penentu kemenangan mereka. Namun, pada tahun 2024, sebagian besar pemilih Latin di Texas Selatan justru memilih untuk tidak menggunakan hak pilihnya atau malah memberikan suara kepada Donald Trump. Akan tetapi, berdasarkan hasil penghitungan awal, banyak dari wilayah tersebut justru menunjukkan dukungan bagi Partai Demokrat dengan selisih suara yang melampaui keunggulan Trump di sana. “Menurut saya, pergeseran yang kita lihat ini akan dianggap sebagai kembalinya pemilih Latin ke ‘rumah’ politik mereka (Partai Demokrat), padahal menurut saya bukan itu yang sebenarnya terjadi,” ujar Melissa Morales, yang kelompoknya, Somos PAC, melakukan kampanye dari pintu ke pintu untuk Partai Demokrat. “Menurut saya, pergeseran dari kiri ke kanan, lalu kembali lagi, menunjukkan bahwa para pemilih merasa seolah-olah mereka tidak memiliki ‘rumah’ politik yang pasti.”

Namun, mungkin itu topik untuk dibahas besok. Di acara perayaan kemenangan James Talarico yang berlokasi di sebuah tempat seni pertunjukan tepi sungai di Austin, para pendukung yang bersukacita berkumpul di atas panggung sembari menantikan Talarico menyampaikan pidato. Lagu “Let’s Groove” dari Earth, Wind & Fire serta “Texas Hold ’Em” dari Beyoncé diputar. Kerumunan massa kemudian mulai meneriakkan tiga huruf yang biasanya sering saya dengar di acara-acara Trump: “U-S-A! U-S-A!” Sesaat sebelum tengah malam, Talarico muncul dari balik tirai biru, membelah kerumunan di atas panggung, lalu mengambil mikrofon dari salah satu mantan muridnya, diiringi oleh lagu Selena yang bersemangat. “Kita baru saja merebut kembali Texas,” ujarnya, yang disambut sorak-sorai meriah dari para hadirin. “Ini adalah kemenangan sebesar Texas, dan kini kita memiliki mandat sebesar Texas,” katanya.

Suasana di acara nonton bareng Partai Demokrat Michigan dipenuhi kegembiraan. Sekitar pukul 9 malam, sang DJ berbicara melalui mikrofon dan berulang kali menggoda hadirin dengan menjanjikan sebuah “pengumuman istimewa” yang akan segera disampaikan. Para wartawan di ruang pers pun bergegas mengemasi barang-barang mereka dan berlari menuju aula utama. Mungkin Abdul El-Sayed akan muncul lebih awal? Ternyata tidak; lagu “Barbie Girl” dari grup Aqua tiba-tiba diputar—entah mengapa—dan “pengumuman” yang dijanjikan baru muncul beberapa saat kemudian. (Pengumuman tersebut berisi proyeksi dari berbagai kantor berita bahwa Partai Demokrat berhasil merebut kembali kursi di DPR.) Namun, semua itu tidak lagi penting. Begitu skala kemenangan partai tersebut mulai terlihat jelas, malam itu pun berubah menjadi perayaan yang terus berlanjut. Sekelompok perempuan kulit hitam menari di depan panggung, sementara seorang penonton merekam kejadian itu dan mengirimkannya kepada seorang teman dengan pesan: “Mereka tahu cara berpesta di Detroit.” Di dekat bagian depan panggung, seorang pria berdiri diam sambil memegang selusin mawar yang hendak ia berikan kepada sang kandidat. Di belakang mereka, sementara kemenangan Partai Demokrat lainnya di berbagai negara bagian terus ditampilkan melalui MS NOW di dua layar besar yang tergantung di atas, seorang wanita bertanya kepada temannya mengapa hasil pemilihan untuk El-Sayed—yang masih dijadwalkan untuk menyampaikan pidatonya—belum juga diumumkan. Penjelasannya di Michigan selalu sama: mereka masih menunggu penghitungan suara dari Wayne County, wilayah dengan populasi terbanyak di negara bagian tersebut, yang mencakup seluruh kota Detroit. Proses masuknya data suara di sana memang selalu lambat. “Wayne County akan segera membuat heboh,” jelas teman wanita tersebut. Kini waktu telah melewati tengah malam. Kerumunan orang masih tetap berada di sana.